Bringing you the
"Good News" of Jesus Christ
and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC
Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's
magisterium
I went to my grandson's Catholic school for
Grandparent's Day last week and during the
morning prayer time they prayed,
"Dear Jesus, through the Immaculate
heart of Mary ..."
and then the prayer.
Jesus is the Son
of God and needs no intercessor.
He sits at the right hand of God, the Father.
Jesus isGod and needs no intercessor.
Why would this prayer be permitted?
Why do we pray through Mary even when
it's Jesus whom
we are asking?
Jesus is our intercessor to the Father
... that is stated over and over again in
the Bible.
Please tell me where in the Bible it says:
that we should pray through Mary
as our intercessor, and
where in the Bible it says Mary
had "an Immaculate heart"?
I really need
to understand these things. As I study the
Bible, they do not make sense to me.
Thank you.
Pam
{
Where
in the Bible does it say we should pray through
the Immaculate heart of Mary plus? }
John
replied:
Hi, Pam —
You ask a very legitimate question.
On the surface, without understand
the theology of the Covenant and
the Incarnation, the Scriptures don't
plainly spell out all Catholic doctrine.
The Church however, has never accepted
the notion that Scripture alone is
it's source. The Church has a teaching
authority along with Sacred Tradition.
Together with the Scriptures, they
make a three legged stool upon which
doctrine safely sits.
I can tell by the way you asked your
question that you are missing some
foundational truths so before we
talk about the Immaculate heart of
Mary, we need to establish a few
things. This may take more than one
e-mail exchange.
Below are my notes from an RCIA,
(Rite of Christian Initiation for
Adults) class on the Communion of
Saints. This should lay down a foundation
for you. It might open up your eyes
to a few things in the Scriptures
as well. Read through them, ponder
them and let's take it from there.
The
Communion of Saints
The word Communion comes
from the Greek word Koinonia from
which we derive the words
fellowship, communion, communication,
and economy. The word Saints
is the Greek word "Hagios".
It can also be translated "holy
ones."
For example, the New American
Bibles reads as follows:
"Paul, an apostle
of Christ Jesus by the
will of God, to the holy
ones (Hagios) who
are in Ephesus"
(Ephesians 1:1)
Whereas the Revised Standard
Version (Catholic Edition)
reads:
"Paul, an apostle
of Christ Jesus by the
will of God, to the saints (Hagios) who
are in Ephesus"
(Ephesians 1:1)
Often times, we only think
of saints as those who have
been canonized (i.e.:
St. Patrick, St. Anthony,
etc.) Other times, we use
the term to refer to all
those in Heaven. However,
the word "Hagios" literally
means: those set apart or
separated from.
In ecclesial
usage, the word Hagios means
those separated from the
world or the (world system) and
thus set apart for God.
Therefore, the broader sense
of the term includes all
Christians, be they on earth,
in Purgatory, or fully perfected
in Heaven.
So "Communion of Saints" is
a term used to describe
the entire Church, the interaction
of all Her members and the
mystical economy that exists
between them. While economy
might sound like strange
word to use, it is very
accurate. Within the Communion
of Saints, there is a sharing
of Spiritual goods. The
prayers, deeds, and offerings
of one member affect the
entire Body of Christ. So
too, the needs, sufferings,
and even sins of any member
impact the entire Body.
This, in essence, describes
an economy.
What does Scripture teach
us about the Communion of
Saints?
Let's start by looking a
key text:
1 Therefore
I exhort first of all
that supplications, prayers,
intercessions, and giving
of thanks be made for
all men, 2 for
kings and all who are
in authority, that we
may lead a quiet and
peaceable life in all
godliness and reverence. 3 For
this is good and acceptable
in the sight of God our
Savior, 4 who
desires all men to be
saved and to come to
the knowledge of the
truth. 5 For
there is one God and
one Mediator between
God and men, the
Man Christ Jesus, 6 who
gave Himself a ransom
for all, to be testified
in due time, 7 for
which I was appointed
a preacher and an apostle
-- I am speaking the
truth in Christ and not
lying-- a teacher of
the Gentiles in faith
and truth. 8 I
desire therefore that
men pray everywhere..."
1 Timothy 2:1-8
The foundation of our doctrine
is rooted in the proper
understanding of verse 5.
"For there is one
God and one Mediator
between God and men,
the Man Christ Jesus,"
Notice Paul's emphasis:
he refers the "the
Man Christ Jesus."
Why is Paul stressing
Jesus' humanity?
Because, the implication
of the Incarnation is that
God intended to include
and involve humanity in
Christ's redemptive work.
Hence, the role of "the
Man Christ Jesus" isn't
meant to exclude the rest
of mankind. To the contrary,
in and through the Incarnation,
Christ saves us and we become
members of His Body. If,
by grace, we are members
of His Body, then also by
grace, we participate in
His mediation and redemptive
work.
St. Peter, in his first
epistle, referred to us
as:
" a chosen generation,
a royal priesthood, a
holy nation, ... that
[we] may proclaim the
praises of Him ..."
1 Peter 2:9
Of course, Peter is not
saying we are all ordained
priests. However, through
our baptism and adoption
into the Body of Christ,
we all share in the Priesthood
of Christ. If we are all
priests, we are, therefore
all mediators by definition,
because the role of priest
is to mediate.
That is what St. Paul is
telling Timothy. Notice
that he doesn't mention
Christ's mediation alone.
Rather, the text is bracketed
by exhortations to pray
and intercede. If
Christ alone is the
exclusive mediator, then
Paul's exhortation makes
no sense.
This brings up two questions:
Are the souls of the
deceased able to witness
what is happening
among the living?
The answer is found in
Hebrews Chapter 12.
1 Therefore,
we also, since we are
surrounded by so great
a cloud of witnesses,
let us lay aside every
weight, and the sin which
so easily ensnares us,
and let us run with endurance
the race that is set
before us.
Hebrews 12:1
Notice the text starts
with the word "therefore".
One of the first rules
of biblical interpretation
is: When you see a "therefore" you
have to find out what
it's there for!
In this instance, the "therefore" is
a reference to all of
Hebrews 11.
This chapter lists the
many Old Testament characters
who died in faith, awaiting
the promised Messiah.
So the author of Hebrews
makes it clear that those
who have gone before
us, surround us and are
very conscious of what
is happening amongst
the living.
The second question then
becomes:
Are these
deceased saints merely
spectators or are we
some how connected with
them in prayer and worship?
Again, the author of
Hebrews answers this
question for us.
22 But
you have come to Mount
Zion and to the city
of the living God, the
heavenly Jerusalem, to
an innumerable company
of angels, 23 to
the general assembly
and church of the firstborn
who are registered in
heaven, to God the Judge
of all, to the spirits
of just men made perfect, 24 to
Jesus the Mediator of
the new covenant, ...
Hebrews 12:22-24
First, notice verse 24.
The author of Hebrews
also mentions Jesus as
the Mediator. But again,
as in Paul's letter to
Timothy, Christ's mediation
is not mentioned in a
vacuum. Quite the contrary,
verse 23 mentions:
the angels
the general assembly
the church registered
in heaven, and
the "spirits
of just men made perfect"
Then finally, Jesus the
Mediator is referenced
in verse 24.
The inspired author is
telling us that the unity
of the Mystical Body
of Christ is organic
and inseparable. Death
has no power of this
unity, just as death
had no power over Christ
Himself.
This understanding is not
a Catholic novelty. This
belief is shared by our
Orthodox Christian brothers
and, just as important,
it also has roots in Jewish
Tradition. The Second Book
of Maccabees records a [vision/dream]
experienced by Judas Maccabeus.
In this vision, Judas sees
the High Priest Onias and
the Prophet Jeremiah (both
of whom were dead and buried)
interceding on behalf of
Israel. (2 Maccabees 15:11-16)
While Maccabees was not
included in the Jewish Canon
in 90A.D. (for political
reasons), Jews still
maintain this belief.
All that being said; we
must remember our starting
point. The Communion of
Saints is rooted in the
doctrine of the Incarnation.
The Saints in heaven, the
souls in Purgatory, just
like the Christians on earth,
are all members of the Mystical
Body of Christ.
Therefore, since we are
all "In
Christ", as Paul
wrote to the Ephesians,
we participate in Christ's
mediation and intercession
for the world.
The
particular role of Mary
Among the Saints, the Blessed
Virgin Mary plays a unique
and privileged role.
As we've established, God,
in choosing to become Man,
ordained that men and women
participate in the redemption
of the human race. Therefore
the Catechism prefixes any
discussion of Mary with
the following text:
487: What the Catholic
faith believes about
Mary is based on what
it believes about Christ,
and what it teaches about
Mary illumines, in turn,
its faith in Christ.
Notice the emphasis: Everything
we believe about Mary is
related to the Incarnation
and it illuminates our Christian
faith. To that end, Mary
becomes our model of the
perfect disciple. Nowhere
is this more evident than
in her response to the Angel
Gabriel.
"Let
it be done to me according
to your word . . ."
With these words, Mary allowed
God's eternal plan for our
salvation to become manifest
in our time and space.
The Catechism puts it this
way:
"Let it be done
to me according to your
word. . ."
494 At the announcement
that she would give birth
to "the Son of the
Most High" without
knowing man, by the power
of the Holy Spirit, Mary
responded with the obedience
of faith, certain that "with
God nothing will be impossible": "Behold,
I am the handmaid of
the Lord; let it be [done]
to me according to your
word." Thus, giving
her consent to God's
word, Mary becomes the
mother of Jesus. Espousing
the divine will for salvation
wholeheartedly, without
a single sin to restrain
her, she gave herself
entirely to the person
and to the work of her
Son; she did so in order
to serve the mystery
of redemption with him
and dependent on him,
by God's grace:
As St. Irenaeus says,
"Being obedient
she became the cause
of salvation for herself
and for the whole
human race."
Hence not a few of the
early Fathers gladly
assert:
"The knot of
Eve's disobedience
was untied by Mary's
obedience: what the
virgin Eve bound through
her disbelief, Mary
loosened by her faith."
Comparing her with Eve,
they call Mary "the
Mother of the living" and
frequently claim: "Death
through Eve, life through
Mary."
Mary, by agreeing to bring
Jesus into the world, became
a "cause" of our
Salvation.
In doing so, she mediated
between Heaven and earth.
Therefore, the Church gives
Mary certain titles such
as Mediatrix of all Grace
and Co-Redemptrix.
Again, when we hear titles
such as these, we must always
remember that these titles
are in no way equating Mary
to Jesus. To the contrary,
they are meant to be understood
in relationship to Jesus
Christ. Mary is what she
is by grace and by virtue
of being "in
Christ." Since
Jesus Christ is the source
of all grace and Mary brought
Jesus into the world, Mary
is the Mediatrix of grace.
Since she cooperated with
God's redemptive plan, she
is Co-Redemptrix.
She is what we must strive
to be. Every time we, by
word or deed, bring someone
closer to Christ we
also function as mediators
and co-redeemers. The
difference is what we do imperfectly,
Mary does perfectly.
With that in mind, there
are five essential doctrines
about Mary which we will
attempt to cover:
The Immaculate Conception
The Virgin Birth
Mary's Perpetual Virginity
Mary, Mother of God
Mary's Assumption into
Heaven
The Catechism states:
The Immaculate Conception
490 To become the mother
of the Savior, Mary "was
enriched by God with
gifts appropriate to
such a role."
The angel Gabriel at
the moment of the annunciation
salutes her as "full
of grace". In fact,
in order for Mary to
be able to give the free
assent of her faith to
the announcement of her
vocation, it was necessary
that she be wholly borne
by God's grace.
491 Through the centuries
the Church has become
ever more aware that
Mary, "full of grace" through
God, was redeemed from
the moment of her conception.
That is what the dogma
of the Immaculate Conception
confesses, as Pope Pius
IX proclaimed in 1854:
The most Blessed Virgin
Mary was, from the
first moment of her
conception, by a singular
grace and privilege
of almighty God and
by virtue of the merits
of Jesus Christ, Savior
of the human race,
preserved immune from
all stain of original
sin.
Mary's virginity
496 From the first formulations
of her faith, the Church
has confessed that Jesus
was conceived solely
by the power of the Holy
Spirit in the womb of
the Virgin Mary, affirming
also the corporeal aspect
of this event: Jesus
was conceived "by
the Holy Spirit without
human seed". The
Fathers see in
the virginal conception
the sign that it truly
was the Son of God who
came in a humanity like
our own. Thus St. Ignatius
of Antioch at the beginning
of the second century
says:
You are firmly convinced
about our Lord, who
is truly of the race
of David according
to the flesh, Son
of God according to
the will and power
of God, truly born
of a virgin,. . .
he was truly nailed
to a tree for us in
his flesh under Pontius
Pilate. . . he truly
suffered, as he is
also truly risen.
499 The deepening of
faith in the virginal
motherhood led the Church
to confess Mary's real
and perpetual virginity
even in the act of giving
birth to the Son of God
made man. In fact, Christ's
birth "did not diminish
his mother's virginal
integrity but sanctified
it."
And so the liturgy of
the Church celebrates
Mary as Aeiparthenos,
the "Ever-virgin".
500 Against this doctrine
the objection is sometimes
raised that the Bible
mentions brothers and
sisters of Jesus. The
Church has always understood
these passages as not
referring to other children
of the Virgin Mary. In
fact, James and
Joseph, "brothers
of Jesus", are the
sons of another Mary,
a disciple of Christ,
whom St. Matthew significantly
calls "the other
Mary". They are
close relations of Jesus,
according to an Old Testament
expression.
501 Jesus is Mary's only
son, but her spiritual
motherhood extends to
all men whom indeed he
came to save: "The
Son whom she brought
forth is he whom God
placed as the first-born
among many brethren,
that is, the faithful
in whose generation and
formation she co-operates
with a mother's love."
Mother of God
467 The Monophysites
affirmed that the human
nature had ceased to
exist as such in Christ
when the divine person
of God's Son assumed
it. Faced with this heresy,
the fourth ecumenical
council, at Chalcedon
in 451A.D., confessed:
Following the holy
Fathers, we unanimously
teach and confess
one and the same Son,
our Lord Jesus Christ:
the same perfect in
divinity and perfect
in humanity, the same
truly God and truly
man, composed of rational
soul and body; consubstantial
with the Father as
to his divinity and
consubstantial with
us as to his humanity; "like
us in all things but
sin". He was
begotten from the
Father before all
ages as to his divinity
and in these last
days, for us and for
our salvation, was
born as to his humanity
of the virgin Mary,
the Mother of God.
Mary’s Assumption
965 After her Son's Ascension,
Mary "aided the
beginnings of the Church
by her prayers."
In her association with
the apostles and several
women, "we also
see Mary by her prayers
imploring the gift of
the Spirit, who had already
overshadowed her in the
Annunciation."
. . . also on her Assumption
966 "Finally the
Immaculate Virgin, preserved
free from all stain of
original sin, when the
course of her earthly
life was finished, was
taken up body and soul
into heavenly glory,
and exalted by the Lord
as Queen over all things,
so that she might be
the more fully conformed
to her Son, the Lord
of lords and conqueror
of sin and death."
The Assumption of the
Blessed Virgin is a singular
participation in her
Son's Resurrection and
an anticipation of the
resurrection of other
Christians:
In giving birth you
kept your virginity;
in your Dormition
you did not leave
the world, O Mother
of God, but were joined
to the source of Life.
You conceived the
living God and, by
your prayers, will
deliver our souls
from death.
Byzantine Liturgy,
Feast of the Dormition
Mary’s Assumption
The Church teaches that
Mary was assumed body and
soul into Heaven. This is
very different from Our
Lord’s Ascension.
Jesus by His own power,
ascended into Heaven. Whereas,
Mary was passively assumed
to Heaven by an act of God.
This teaching of the Church
was elevated to a dogma
in 1950, but has been a
belief of the Church going
back to the earliest of
times.
There are two different
traditions.
In the East, it is said
that she died first.
In the West, the tradition
is that she was assumed
before dying.
In either case, the Church
believes she is in Heaven
with her glorified body,
as we hope to be after the
Resurrection of the dead.
There is no specific Biblical
text that tells us Mary
was assumed. However, we
must bear in mind that the
Gospels were probably written
prior to the event. Moreover,
the Gospels were about the
life of Christ. The author’s
intent was not to give us
a play-by-play description
of every truth the Church
teaches.
That said, there is Biblical
precedent for Mary’s
assumption.
In the book of Kings,
we read about Elijah
the Prophet being taken
to heaven in a Chariot
of fire as his apprentice
Elisha looked on.
In Genesis, a character
named Enoch is said to
be “taken away”
and finally,
the Epistle of St.
Jude tells of a battle
over Moses body that
took place between Michael
the Archangel and Satan.
Finally, there are several
writings of the Early Church
Fathers which support this
Tradition.
I hope this helps,
John
Eric
replied:
Hi, Pam —
You ask an important question. I
have a few things to add to what
my colleague has said.
First, Jesus is the mediator between
God, the Father and man. The prayer
you cited expressed mediation between
Mary and Jesus. This does not violate
Jesus's mediatorship because Mary
does not mediate with the Father,
but with the Son.
It may seem a small point but I think
it's an important one. In mediating,
she does nothing more than bring
us to Jesus, which is exactly what
all the rest of us are called to
do as well. She says to us, "Do
whatever he tells you" (John
2:5). All of us are called to be
ambassadors for Christ and reconcile
sinners to him (2 Corinthians 5:20).
This is mediation: Acting as an intermediary,
an ambassador, between Christ and
sinners, reconciling estranged parties.
We also act as mediators when we
intercede for one another (1 Timothy
2:1), for intercession and mediatorship
are synonymous. (Note the prayer
you objected to was merely asking
Mary for her intercession, which
is commanded by 1 Timothy 2:1.) Evangelizing
people is a form of mediatorship,
too.
In short, Mary is mediatrix because
she symbolizes what the whole people
of God are called to do:
Bring people to Christ. "Do whatever
he tells you." That's all it is
about.
I'd also like to point out some texts
from Psalm 45. Psalm 45 speaks mainly
of two people:
The King-Messiah (Christ) and
his Queen (Mary).
In Judaism, because of polygamy,
the queen was typically the mother
of the king, not his wife. Revelation
12 portrays this queen (we know
she's queen because she has a crown
and is dressed in splendor, much
like the figure in Psalm 45). Psalm
45:12 says,
"And the daughter of Tyre
shall be there with a gift; even
the rich among the people shall
intreat thy favour."
People will ask the queen for favors.
She will make her sons princes over
the earth (verse 16). Compare this
to Revelation 12:17, where those
who
"keep the commands of God
and bear testimony to Jesus"
are identified as the offspring of
the woman clothed with the sun (the
queen). Finally, compare verse 17
"I will make thy name to
be remembered in all generations:
therefore shall the people praise
thee for ever and ever"
with the Magnificat in Luke 1:48
("All generations will call
me blessed").
Eric
Please
report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey