Bringing you the
"Good News" of Jesus Christ
and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC
Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's
magisterium
I was just wondering about the verse in the Matthew where
Jesus says not to call anyone Father or Rabbi, because there
is only one Master.
And also Luke 11:27, 28:
27 As Jesus was saying these things, a woman in the crowd
called out, "Blessed is the mother who gave you birth
and nursed you." 28 He replied, "Blessed rather
are those who hear the word of God and obey it."
Why do Catholics feel the need to pray to Mary when Jesus
tells us to pray through Him alone?
I'm not trying to be rude, I just don't see how these several beliefs
add up with these several scriptures.
Oh, P.S. I'm 23, I live in the U.S. I am a man who is getting
married in three days. I was raised in the Methodist church,
but now attend a non-denominational church.
Thanks for your time and for any answers you can give me.
Joshua
{
Scripture says, "Call no man
father" and why do Catholics feel the need to pray to Mary? }
Eric replied:
Hi Joshua,
Thanks for your question. We actually already have an answers on the site
to your questions. See
Hope this helps, let us know if there is any follow up question you have.
Eric Ewanco
Bob replied:
Joshua,
Congratulations on your marriage. I wish you many blessings and that God will truly
provide you with a holy and powerful union.
Regarding your questions; I know you are busy with nuptial affairs, but when you
have a moment, please check these thoughts out.
#1.
With respect to Jesus admonition to call no man "father, teacher or master" we
must determine what his context and intent is. If he meant it literally, we should
call no man such in any sense. Biological or adopted children could not refer to
their male parent as such, nor could we address Doctors (which means teacher) as
such. However, against this, even Jesus himself makes such references of human being
and their parents, i.e., Mk 20:29. Furthermore, there is a commandment which demands
that we bring honor to our Father and Mother. In addition, history bears out that
this interpretation has seldom been accepted, and not without a very subjective partial
adherence. A completely literal interpretation is not accepted anywhere.
So then, he must mean it in a non literal sense. A symbolic or spiritual sense may
be implied, but to what extent and in what circumstance? Does Jesus mean to suggest
that no man be considered a spiritual father in any case? Against this, Paul himself
would be violating such an admonition. He calls himself "father" (a far
more arrogant use of the word than by another) with respect to Onesimus (Philippians
1:10), and "teacher", 2 Timothy 2:11 and implies it with Timothy and Titus, "a
true child in the faith" (cf. 1 Timothy 1:1). So being a symbolic or spiritual
Father or Teacher is not inconsistent with Scripture and Tradition. Paul would be
leading us contrary to Jesus' words if that was the case.
What then may be the context and intent that Jesus implies? There was in Jesus' time,
as in our own, a tendency to identify a particular individual as an enlightened one,
one who is capable by his own power of showing the way to salvation. A guru in short.
In Acts 16, Paul rebukes a woman who had proclaimed they had "a way" of
salvation; as if there were several. Jesus is the only way, and Paul and all Apostles
who follow him authentically know this and won't tolerate being lauded as an enlightened
leader. This is the kind of arrogance Jesus rebukes, and the false discipleship that
goes with it. Sadly, there will always be the charlatans that seek to dupe people
into following their way. These counterfeits propose to be a sort of God on earth
with their own recipe for salvation. Essentially, our understanding of Jesus' admonition
is against those that claim and follow a way contrary to the "true" way
in Christ himself.
Finally, Catholics use the word "father" as a title in recognition of the
important role that God the true Father has given to his Apostles and their assistants.
We consider the Church "the family" of God, and the titles are fittingly
given, for a father helps raise the children to their own full stature. This is how
Paul, and I'm sure the other Apostles, viewed their role beyond being mere instructors.
A close reading of Paul in his epistles will reveal this attitude sharply.
#2.
Jesus is merely pointing out the obvious, Mary isn't blessed because she had breasts
and suckled Jesus, but because she did "hear the word of God and obey it." Remember
Elizabeth's words, "blessed is she who believed that what was spoken to you
by the Lord would be fulfilled." (Luke 1:45)
We honor Mary because Jesus gave her to us as a gift (cf. Jn 19:26-27, we believe
the beloved disciple represents each of us, not merely John, who is unnamed--a theme
throughout this Gospel) We pray to saints only in as much as we consider them part
of the family of God and seek their prayers for us--they have no power on their own.
They are powerful intercessors only, as any holy person is. While Protestants often
object on the grounds that we are to have no contact with the "dead", we
say they are "alive" in Christ. And what are we to make of Jesus' interactions
with Moses and Elijah on the mount of Transfiguration? Did he have illicit contact
with the dead? We are a family, and while, unlike Jesus, we can't see with our eyes
those who spur us on to Holiness, we believe we are surrounded by a "cloud of
witnesses" (Hebrews 12:1) that bid our good blessing in this race to the finish
line and intercede for a hastening of our redemption (Revelation 6:9-11).
I realize this has gone on for longer than I intended, but this hardly scratches
this last subject. I hope you will continue to read the scriptures and consult history
for the fullest understanding of the gift which has been handed us.
Peace,
Bob Kirby
Joshua replied:
I do wonder about this section of one of your answers for this
posting.
Mary helps us get to Jesus so Jesus can get us to heaven. Just as you work
to bring people to Jesus so that they may be reconciled to Jesus and hence saved
-- an act called mediation -- we believe that Mary works to bring people to
Jesus so that they may be saved. We even ask Mary to help us get to Jesus so
that we might be saved.
I understand that this is what you believe, but I really see no REASON why
you believe it. Where in the Bible does it say that Mary can help us get to
Jesus?
Joshua
Eric replied:
Hi Joshua,
Anyone (except those in Hell) can help us get to Jesus, whether it's by
praying for us, witnessing to us, or even serving as a counterexample.
I suppose the question behind your question is, how can Mary, who is in
heaven, help us get to heaven according to the Scriptures.
To that I would answer,
on account of her prayers. This is part of a doctrine known as the communion
of saints, which is a very ancient one (it appears in the Apostle's Creed
and is testified to in the catacombs of Rome). First of all, the saints
are present with us. You can see this in Hebrews chapter 12, verses 1 and
23. Verse one, after listing a bunch of Old Testament saints, concludes
saying "Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of
witnesses ...", thus teaching that the saints surround us like a cloud,
cheering us on as it were in the Christian life. Later on, Christian worship
is described, and present at that worship are the "spirits of just
men made perfect" -- the saints in heaven. Since they are present
with us, it is reasonable to conclude that they can hear us. In fact, in
Revelation 5:8, we see certain saints carrying our prayers to the throneroom
of God, proving again that they have a role in our prayers.
Now, do they actually pray for us? This seems suggested by Jeremiah 15:1
where God's comment, "Though Moses and Samuel stood before me, yet
my heart would not turn toward this people" indicates that there is
intercession going on the part of the saints (note that Moses and Samuel's
lives did not overlap with each other or with Jeremiah's by hundreds of
years).
Therefore, we can conclude that the saints are around us, can hear us,
and pray for us. But what about Mary's role? Consider Psalm 45, verses
9-17. First look at verse 17, which speaks of the queen: "I will
cause your name to be celebrated in all generations; therefore the peoples
will praise you for ever." What does that evoke? Mary's words in
the Magnificat, "All generations will call me blessed."
The
Psalm refers to a king and a queen. The king is the messiah; the queen
is his queen. But Jewish kings crowned, not their wives (for they had many),
but their mothers'' queen. (see 2 Kings 10:13, Jeremiah 13:18, 1 Kings
2:19). This is in agreement with Revelation 12, which portrays the mother
of the Messiah with a crown on her head in queenly splendor. So, Psalm
45 is, at least in one sense, about Mary. It says, "Instead of your
fathers shall be your sons, you will make them princes in all the earth." So
there is a type of intercession going on here, where Mary can make her
sons princes in all the earth. If she can make them princes on earth, how
much more can she also bring them to salvation through her son Jesus Christ?
So that is in part the biblical basis for Mary being able to help us get
to Jesus. She can pray for us, and through those prayers ("the prayer
of a righteous man is powerful and effective", James 5:16) bring us
to God.
Eric
Joshua replied:
Bob,
I just got back from my honeymoon and finally got to read this.
I greatly appreciate
the time you took to answer my questions. It has given me great insight.
Thanks
again,
Joshua
Please
report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey